On Norfolk Island, stories await around every turn, and Headstone Reserve is the setting for one of our most gripping.

According to legend, an escaped convict by the name of Barney Duffy placed a curse on the soldiers who recaptured him. His captors then drowned at Headstone Point, earning it the nickname Barney Duffy Gully.

Today, you’ll see a lone headstone standing sentry over the craggy coast, commemorating the drowning of two British soldiers. Gripping as this yarn is, the timing doesn’t quite line up: the headstone dates the soldiers’ death to 1850, but historical documents indicate the name Barney Duffy Gully was in use since at least the late 1830s.

From the cliff edge, you might be able to make out the remnants of steps, which used to provide access to passengers coming ashore from boats. The steps have long since eroded, but some hardy locals still use them to reach prime rock-fishing spots.